Mattingly's Tavern Menu

  1. Overview
  2. Menu
Mattingly's Tavern 1
Mattingly's Tavern 2
Mattingly's Tavern 3
Mattingly's Tavern 4
Mattingly's Tavern 5
Mattingly's Tavern 6
Mattingly's Tavern 7
Mattingly's Tavern 8
Mattingly's Tavern 9

Welcome to Mattingly's Tavern, a vibrant dining spot located at 16 N Main St, Florida, NY. This establishment has earned a reputation for its welcoming atmosphere and a menu that reflects comfort and creativity. The highlight of their offerings is undoubtedly the burgers, particularly the Four Cheese Jack Daniel's burger, which has garnered rave reviews for its rich flavor and indulgent layers.

Guests also rave about the unique potato flats, seasoned with a special "magic dust" that elevates them beyond standard fries. For those who prefer a lighter fare, the tavern boasts phenomenal wings, with flavors like garlic parmesan and Jack Daniel's Honey BBQ that keep patrons coming back for more.

With friendly service and a diverse beer selection, Mattingly's Tavern not only satisfies your palate but also creates a lively social hub. Whether you’re catching a game or enjoying live music, this tavern offers an experience that goes beyond dining.

Beer Bottles/Cans
Starters
Long Relief
Add-Ons
Wine
Non-Alcoholic
Closers
Secret Menu
Non-Food Items
Brunch

Beer Bottles/Cans

Miller Lite - Bottle
US$4.39

Bud Light - BOTTLE
US$4.39

Corona - Bottle
US$6.47

Coors Light - Bottle
US$4.39

Yuengling BOTTLE
US$4.39

Budweiser - Bottle
US$4.39

Modelo Bottle
US$6.47

Twisted Tea BOTTLE
US$6.47

Rolling Rock
US$3.78

Fried Mozzarella
US$9.00

Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats APPETIZER
US$9.00

Colossal Pretzel
US$7.00

Starter Sampler
US$14.00

Half Order Of Wings (6)
US$10.00

Fried Pickles
US$9.00

Bacon & Cheese Loaded Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats APPETIZER
US$11.00

Beer-Battered Onion Rings
US$9.00

Mac 'N' Cheese Triangles
US$9.00

Jalepeno Poppers
US$9.00

Starters

Long Relief

Wings
US$15.00

Chicken Tenders W/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
US$13.00

Grilled Chicken Sandwich W/Tavern Seasoned Potato Flats
US$13.00

Caramelized Onion Swiss Burger With Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
US$16.00

Stadium Dogs & Fries
US$13.00

Beer-Battered Fish Sandwich
US$14.00

Gorgonzola Bacon With Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
US$16.00

Bacon Cheeseburger
US$16.00

Beyond Burger
US$18.00

Grilled Cheese Special
US$13.00

Grilled Cheese On Pretzel Bun W/Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats
US$13.00

Tavern Salad
US$14.00

Stand-Up Double Steakburger
US$19.00

Triple Crown Steakburger
US$23.00

Add-On Chicken Tenders
US$5.00

Add-On Steak
US$12.00

Add-On America Cheese
US$2.00

Add-On Cod
US$4.00

Add-On Grilled Chicken
US$5.00

Add-On Bacon
US$3.00

Add-On Premium Sauce - Bleu Cheese
US$2.00

Add-On Premium Sauce - Ranch
US$2.00

Add-On Pretzel Bun
US$4.00

Add-On BBQ Sauce Side
US$2.00

Add-On Buffalo Sauce Side
US$2.00

Add-On Garlic Parmesan Sauce Side
US$2.00

Tavern Coleslaw
US$3.00

Add-On Honey Mustard Sauce Side
US$2.00

Add-On Barbecue Sauce Side
US$2.00

Add-On Barbecue Tang Sauce
US$2.00

Add-On Jack Honey Bourbon Sauce
US$2.00

Add-On Teriyaki Peanut Sauce
US$2.00

Add-On Swiss Cheese
US$2.00

Add-On Red Sauce
US$2.00

Add-On Gorgonzola Cheese
US$2.00

Add-On Fried Egg
US$2.00

Substitute Onion Rings
US$4.00

Add-On Candied Walnuts
US$4.00

Gluten-Free Bun - Substitution
US$3.00

Add Beyond Burger
US$7.00

Add Burger
US$7.00

Add-Ons

Wine

Prosecco
US$11.18

Dom Perignon Champagne (2010)
US$269.00

Soft Drinks
US$4.00

Coffee
US$4.00

Red Bull
US$6.48

Orange Juice
US$4.00

Shirley Temple
US$5.00

Tea
US$4.00

Cranberry Juice
US$4.00

Pineapple Juice
US$4.00

Virgin Bloody Mary
US$6.00

Chocolate Milk Box
US$4.00

Non-Alcoholic

Closers

Fried Oreo Cookies
US$7.00

60 Party Wings
US$84.00

120 Party Wings
US$135.00

30 Party Wings
US$43.00

30 Party Wings (Cloned)
US$56.00

Burgers & Bourbons
US$35.00

Secret Menu

Non-Food Items

Magic Dust Tavern Seasoning
US$15.00

Mattingly's Tavern T-Shirt
US$20.00

Copy Of Mattingly's Hoodie "Pour Decisions"
US$25.00

Add-On Fried Egg
US$2.00

Brunch